TimB: If one does not recognize the beauty in the picture above, (and I am sure that there are many who don’t) then, imo, their reality is diminished. But whether they feel fear, annoyance, disgust, or some other emotion, those feelings are also part of reality.
Xain: Not true, they simply have woken up to the way that things are. As for emotions they are not valid or real, at least that is what Buddhism says (a la the Heart Sutra).
TimB: I could say that Buddhism (a la the Heart Sutra) is not valid or real. That it is all just a cacophony of concepts. At least emotions have potentially observable correlates. Can you show evidence that Buddhist claims are real?
Xain: You pointing to pictures as examples of beauty means nothing and they aren’t evidence either.
TimB: The pictures that I presented are examples of beauty to me. And I know that because I have a pleasant feeling when I see them. I would not have the same feeling if I were looking at a Grecian Urn, but that’s just me. Some say “beauty is in the eye of the beholder”. So beauty does not seem to be experienced the same across different individual’s perception. Still the emotions that it evokes are real.
Xain: That Gretta girl is too naive to understand how humans function, that what served just thousands of years ago is now killing us (and is likely a case for why modernity is a mistake).
TimB: Idk what you mean by “what served just thousands of years ago is now killing us (and is likely a case for why modernity is a mistake)”.
Xain: She has yet to learn, but like other idealistic youths she will.
TimB: She doesn’t seem to me to be naïve. She knows the issues of Climate Change better than most of the people running the world today. She recognizes that the powers that be, will continue to say nice things about what they will do to combat climate change, while actually doing little or nothing. She is only idealistic in that she keeps trying in the face of little actual hope. And she is aware of that, too. Having ideals may well eventually be beaten out of her by experience, but in the meantime, it is, imo, an excellent bit of meaning for her life. And in the meantime, she will be beautiful. Beauty exists in moments, not perpetually. Nothing lasts forever.
And btw, having ideals is not the sole domain of the young. Having ideals is a critical component of being a healthy human. (Unless of course you can be a Buddhist who is above all that. Can you be a Buddhist who is above all that, Xain?) And if you can, then what?