This video triggered a certain breakthrough for me.
~ 4:45
Mary’s Room Thought Experiment,
The thing is, we are first and foremost Evolved Biological Beings.
Our “experience” is fundamentally different from intellectual “knowing”.
The problem is that Mary’s Thought Experiment is oblivious (or is it dismissive) to the fact that our intellectual experience isn’t limited to our brain’s information processing abilities - the cells of our body are an active component of the mind’s mental processing and our ‘experiencing’!
And this brings us back to the importance of a deep awareness of the physical reality ~ human mindscape divide is essential before any of the rest of it can start making sense.
8:00 Jackson discusses, “physical information” but he never seems to get to thinking about the inputs coming from throughout our bodies, or for that matter also from the physical environment constantly interactions with our bodies, which are an extension of our brain.
8:57 - Kaplan
"we were initially inclined to define physicalism in terms of objects in the world,
and now we’re talking entirely in terms of facts or information about objects.
I guess so, that’s a little weird, maybe that’s not a problem at all.But it is the crucial move right because the example of mary’s room is an example of someone who doesn’t encounter some new objects exactly it’s an example of someone who learns a new type of fact a new piece of information"
~ 4:45 The thing is, we are first and foremost Evolved Biological Beings.
Our “experience” is fundamentally different from intellectual “knowing”.
The Mary’s Thought Experiment is oblivious (or is it dismissive) to the fact that our intellectual experience isn’t limited to our brain’s information processing abilities - the cells of our body are an active component of our mind’s mental processing and our ‘experiencing’! That’s why an experience is more meaningful than all the information in the world.
Human awareness of the physical reality ~ human mindscape divide is essential before any of those questions can start making sense of the reality we live. As opposed to the drama unfolding within out minds.
Or to put it more poetically, Jackson drives way beyond his headlights (the facts he possesses).
12:50 Epiphenomenalism -
Epiphenomenal and such, besides reinforcing my above sentiment, spotlights why I sincerely believe that philosophy without a deep thorough knowledge of our biological evolutionary roots unfolding over deep time, a doomed exercise.
As for the Princess Elizabeth Problem
17:35 - Kaplan
Princess Elizabeth points out that seems totally impossible. If the mind is not itself physical if the mind is not material stuff extended in space then it can’t get into space to move things around like move the move the the fingers or move the neurons in my brain or anything.Like that was the problem was stuff causes stuff to happen in the world, and so that seemed like it was a problem for dualism.
It’s difficult to understand how such an Argument From Ignorance can still be batted around in this age of Electricity.