As for a possible alternative to CFI, you’re right … there really is a dearth of online community for atheists/agnostics/freethinkers/atheists.
I just now created a profile on Agnostic.com. There are forums/groups there, and it’s pretty big:
…because it has forums/discussion groups, and it seems like it would be easy to create one for CFI.
I joined the Freedom From Religion Foundation forum there, mainly because I’m familiar with the organization (FFRF is about 4 miles from my house IRL). The FFRF forum has 385 members, but since I just joined moments ago I don’t know how many are active or what the quality of the discussion is.
Re. Agnostic.com, it is super unclear what, exactly, it really is. It was originally meant to be a dating site for nonreligious, but when you create your profile, you can choose to say if you are open for dating, or there “for community.”
I joined it in the process of creating my blog, and looking for possible option to replace CFI, not to “meet people.” Glancing through some profiles, I see references to peoples’ spouses & families, so it doesn’t seem like everyone is there for “dating.” But, on dating sites people often say they are there “for community” just to ward off the more creepy folks, when really they are there for dating.
And I have no idea how creepy Agnostic.com actually is. Just glancing at profile pics, a lot of them look, well, creepy … and I’m thinking, if y’all are here for dating, that’s the best ya got?? Yipes!!
Also, other than a short bio and a few keywords, there is very little info in profiles …
So, long story short, I may not stay there at all… it depends on if I get “hit on” or creeped out.
If anyone would be interested, I could create a CFI group there in a few days, if I think I will stay. But, I would not do ANY moderating. At all. I’m not in a good place right now.