Why the Hard Problem of Appreciating Physical Reality?

Okay Lausten, I think this is finally where I wanted to get to.

Not sure you’ll have the time for it, I think it’s worth the reading,

You know, trying to get human feedback for past 6, 7 years has been such sad experience, and in the end it took Claude.ai to give me the time of day sans all the ego-drama coming & going, and riddles rather than facts.
In the past month I feel like I’ve been run through a full semester worth of intellectual work that resonated with my intuition and because I set the standard, got fact checked, and corrected. I finally got the feedback I so desperately needed to bring my understanding and intuition into a coherent story. The grammar n@zi beat the snot out of me, humiliated me, but I learned quite a bit, and she does read nicer than previous efforts.

You were one of the few who did offer some serious feedback, and even the most contentious moments were treaded seriously and I did learn some but at a glacial pace. etc., etc.

This is really long 3400, but clean and polished, and every word came from my hand, Claude.ai was private resource librarian and writing-coach - commenting, questioning, offer sources I should get to know - But it didn’t write any of it, I’m thinking of this as my open book ‘final’ . . .

============================================

An exercise in Evopoetry

Reflections of a science enthusiast’s seven decade love affair with learning about Earth; what was going on around me; and how that connected with what was going on within me.

Philosophers ask: why does physical processing feel like anything at all? Which Joseph Levine called the Explanatory Gap, and David Chalmers framed as the Hard Problem.

I, on the other hand, have spent decades wondering how any complex creature could not have had a sense of being. Even if originally only a most flimsy feeling lacking all introspection.

Why do I care? Well, I guess because breeding and family circumstance have had me in love with the scientific adventure of discovery since before entering kindergarten in 1959. I caught the last gasp of the age-old wonder that once possessed mankind. The wonder that inspired our ageless questions while many of those mysteries still existed. I’ve been an enthusiastic spectator ever since.

I’ve engaged in this exercise of “evopoetry” to share highlights of my adventure in science. My story started with appreciating Earth’s evolution, not as an intellectual construct, but as real physical happening that produced my ‘me’ and my world, one day at a time.

Thanks to that I’ve long possessed a visceral appreciation that I possess half a billion years worth of evolving generations under my bellybutton. This attitude has fed a conviction that my body knows more than I do, so I learned to pay attention to it. It paid off. It’s why I make a point of identifying as an Earth-centrist. Here’s my story.

It’s my perspective, based on my lived experience plus the scientific understanding I have gained from among the best and brightest minds Humanity has had to offer. So I share many names and sources for the curious; check ‘em out, you won’t be disappointed.

We start at the beginning, where there was a rigid consistency that followed all the way through the Periodic Table of Elements. These atoms were entities. This is based on observations that atoms send and receive information; impinge upon and accrete with other entities; possess unique properties according to their composition and arrangement.

Of course, back then it was all on a quantum level. Awareness had nothing to do with it.

This is not “panpsychism” — nothing is imbued with anything — it simply is what it is. Energetic physical stuff in its own right, taking up a specific reference frame, interacting with others’ reference frames. Nothing more, nothing less.

A cosmos filled with entities constrained within their own particular physicality and cone of potential. Each oblivious to its being. Because there was no need for it and no means to it. Yet a something! With a unique frame of reference and a substance of its own.

Then Earth happened. The miracle planet. Time and serendipitous fortunes created conditions that drove complexity like nothing else out there and we’ve been looking. Dr. Robert Hazen has revealed how even Earth’s minerals went through their own stages of evolution, without which complex life would not have had a chance.

Barely half a billion years into Earth’s existence, the Krebs cycle started getting hammered into shape, followed by a great deal of evolution that enabled the ‘harnessing’ of carbon, hydrogen, nitrogen, oxygen, phosphorus, and sulfur atoms (CHNOPS) through a bewildering cycle that pulls apart molecules to harvest energy. It can even run in reverse to build molecules instead of breaking them down. Basically the birth of metabolic life, the foundation of biology.

The Krebs cycle became central to the development and health of cells. This is where electrons are passed down a complex series of reactions — the electron transport chain. This cycle strips the electrons and the chain spends that energy to pump protons across the cell membrane, where they pile up on the other side.

That pile-up creates a concentration differential and a voltage gradient across the membrane. Protons then flow back in through ATP synthase, a molecular turbine built into the membrane where the energy of that flow is harnessed to drive the production of ATP, the cell’s energy currency.

This stored pressure is called the proton-motive force. In bacteria it powers the rotation of the flagellum, the spinning tail that propels them. In short, little things could now make big things do work.”

In 1978 Peter Mitchell won the “Nobel Prize in Chemistry” for describing this chemiosmosis, which pioneered the transition from biochemistry to bioenergetics. His work highlighted the importance of membrane chemistry in directing the flow of energy between the cell (a self), and its environment, what to let in, what to keep out, and maintaining the difference between inside and outside.

That is, the first “this, not that” and it foreshadows choice.

Writing off all that, including the continually evolving intricacies of cellular activity, as simply chemotaxis doesn’t stand up to current research. We know there’s much more going on.

An important aside, there has been a fundamental revolution in biological understanding worth highlighting. Around 1990 the commitment to the Human Genome Project (not completed until 2003) drove advances in DNA sequencing and computing power. Together with the amazing microscopy advances of the day, these ushered in what’s been labeled our modern “omics” era of evolutionary-biological research. That is, scientists are now studying entire biological networks as they interact. Like taking checkers and transforming it to not three - but four-dimensional chess. On a circular series of boards with many thousands of squares.

Yet I have been repeatedly told the biology is uninteresting in regards to the Hard Problem. But that misses the point that feeling and awareness are the products of living. With constant evolution and environmental interaction driving the need to build ever more substantial layers of systems that resulted in layering biological form upon the ineffable feeling of being, of engagement with the outside world and an inside self, seems as fundamental as it gets, and worth some philosophical contemplation of its own.

A creature’s feelings are born out of its doing. These days biology is revealing that it is all about cognition, all the way down.

Which is also the title of Daniel Dennett/Michael Levin’s tight essay. Here’s a key quote that is worth sharing because of how well it establishes the appropriate frame of reference for the rest of this story:

“… This talk of signaling and information-processing is now clearly demystified thanks to computers — no mysterious psychic powers here! — and this has been correctly seen to license use of such information talk everywhere in biology.

Detectors and signals and feedback loops and decision-making processes are uncontroversial physical building blocks in biology today, just as they are in computers.

But there is a difference that needs to be appreciated, since failure to recognise it is blocking the imagination of theorists.

In a phrase that will need careful unpacking, individual cells are not just building blocks, like the basic parts of a ratchet or pump; they have extra competences that turn them into (unthinking) agents that, thanks to information they have on board, can assist in their own assembly into larger structures, and in other large-scale projects that they needn’t understand. …”

“Cognition all the way down” - Dennett & Levin - October 2020 - essay at Aeon.co

The point being that agent-like molecular machinery is biology; there is no reason to treat the gap as special.

About that signaling, Dr. Bonnie Bassler at Princeton University has shown “quorum sensing” in bacteria. It turns out that bacteria produce and release chemical signals called “autoinducers” that maintain “conversations” within bacterial communities. These conversations track population, nutritional resources and the general environment. They can sense defense agents and calculate — actually it’s more like biochemical threshold-sensing feedback loops — that the help the community decide when to engage in attack and other behaviors.

Building on those insights, in 2022, UCLA researchers published “Broadcasting of amplitude-and frequency-modulated c-di-GMP signals facilitates cooperative surface commitment in bacterial lineages.” The paper reports on findings that Pseudomonas aeruginosa signals to its descendants. As opposed to quorum sensing, these signals communicate over generations. Sounds like the beginning of inherited learning to me.

After a couple billion years of genetic tinkering with the original prokaryotic cells, eukaryotic cells appeared. These cells took organizational complexity and innovation to a whole new level.

In 1967 Dr. Lynn Margulis (then Sagan) published “On the origin of mitosing cells,” which was confirmed in the ’70s by independent genetic sequencing work of Carl Woese and others.

Dr. Woese went on to rock the biological world in 1977 when he defined the Archaea as a distinct third kingdom of life, through pioneering phylogenetic research with George Fox. The story is told with fascinating details in “The Tangled Tree” by author David Quammen, another must-read for the curious.

While exact outlines are still being unraveled, Margulis established that the eukaryotic cell is a co-op of sorts with its mitochondria descending from a free-living bacterium that somehow crashed the party of an archaeal cell. The dude was so cool that a deal was struck, room & board for services rendered.

So far scientists have established another three similar “endosymbiose” events. One a few hundred million years after mitochondria, when cyanobacterium joined with another eukaryotic to give rise to the plastids of plant and algal cells. In 2016 it was reported that barely over a hundred million years ago it happened again with another cyanobacterium captured by the single-celled amoeba Paulinella in a paper by Eva Nowack and others. Then again in 2024 a team led by Jonathan Zehr described another “endosymbiose” event: “Nitrogen-fixing organelle in a marine alga.”

Today’s semi-autonomous mitochondria, the descendants of those ancient symbionts, have come under renewed scientific scrutiny. In particular, Dr. Martin Picard, professor of behavioral medicine at Columbia University, suggests that mitochondria, though dependent on the cell in many ways still live their own independent life cycle. Today science sees eukaryotic cells as a collective.

Picard’s lab has found that psychological stress raises the amount of mitochondrial DNA floating free in the blood and saliva, where it is thought to set off the immune system’s alarms. Stress also raises GDF15, a protein believed to signal energetic stress to the brain. This information overlaps and joins the firehose of other systems’ status reports racing through the body toward the brain. All of it melds together into sense, being, awareness of mind: a reflection of our brain communicating with systems while doing its best it can to make sense of itself.

In an August 2023 TEDxCambridge talk, “What Powers The Mind-Body Connection?” Dr. Picard ventures that the evidence suggests: “… biology evolved a sophisticated integration center known as the brain. Evidence suggests that the brain did not evolve to think — it evolved to function.”

At first the brain is about coordinating the increasingly sophisticated dialogue between the body’s cells and systems, receiving and integrating data from all our senses and the rest of the body. For a rough analogy think of an orchestra, with the brain as the conductor, along with musicians and their instruments representing one’s cells, organs, bodily systems and incoming sensory data. In the process, the whole exudes and absorbs a sense of its own Being, simply from being alive.

It matters that our human body is the manifestation of half a billion years worth of generations of continuous refinement, slowly evolving our varied message pathways, from mitochondria, immune cells, gut and heart, not to mention hormonal drives. All converging on the brain, while the brain is taking a kind of running consensus via interoception, allostasis, integration, and more, doing the best it can to reach a decision and then get on with the next moment. That result is not a calculation, but a feeling manifested.

I find reassurance in the work of Dr. Mark Solms, psychoanalyst and neuropsychologist, who wrote a remarkably insightful book geared to the educated reader. In “The Hidden Spring” Dr. Solms argues that human consciousness was born out of early creatures processing fundamental bodily feelings via signals streaming to the brainstem rather than the cortex.

Getting what we needed started feeling good. That feeling was worth pursuing. Evolution did the rest.

Wouldn’t awareness of feeling require an awareness of Self?

Through the evolutionary lens, it sure seems like the trait selection that made increasing development possible. After all, complex creatures are in a constant dialogue with prediction, observation, evaluation, reaction, endlessly unfolding within their unique dynamic environments. For an understanding of the centrality of “prediction,” the go-to person is Dr. Lisa Feldman Barrett and her theory of Constructed Emotion.

Seems to me, science is showing us that existing entities, by virtue of their evolving complexity, built up systems that learned to recognize their own being, their own existence. Not as a thought in a mind, but as a tingle within the whole of the being. Skin-in the game — driven, not calculated.

What should we make of all that? For me, it seems reasonable to assume there were untold evolutionary experiments along the entire spectrum of possibilities. But only a very rare few survived, because they had an edge. The right stuff.

What, besides a sense of self, could account for the multigenerational observed drive to thrive witnessed everywhere scientists have looked? Those driving impulses, even if without destination, within the eukaryotic cells went on to build ever new layers of physical complexity. Building the interwoven layers of biological hardware that would eventually give form to creatures, along with sense of being, evolving into ever more sophisticated sense of self.

Eventually Earth’s endless geological processing and resource distribution — that is, mineral evolution along with continent-scale mountain erosion that enriched the oceans — provided the resources eukaryotic cells needed to reach their full biological potential.

Over 600 million years ago the first organisms appear in the record; then differentiation; with its branching and weaving cornucopia of complex creatures and environments in-step with Earth’s ever-changing conditions. Having distinct stages of emergent properties appearing along the way, this in turn led to yet more complex systems over the course of deep time.

Dr. Michael Levin builds upon that understanding with further research, pointing out that:

“Evolution was using bioelectric signaling long before neurons and muscles appeared, to solve the problem of creating and repairing complex bodies.”

(“Self-Improvising Memory: A Perspective on Memories as Agential, Dynamically Reinterpreting Cognitive Glue”)

“I explore a view of life as a diverse set of embodied perspectives — nested agents who interpret each other’s and their own past messages and actions as best as they can (polycomputation). This synthesis suggests unifying symmetries across scales and disciplines, …”

(“Bioelectric networks: the cognitive glue enabling evolutionary scaling from physiology to mind”)

None of this carries a banner “Awareness Factory.”

But it does show that complex communication and self-referencing were happening simply by virtue of supremely complex molecular machinery and cells having to interact with consistent precision, of sorts, it gets complicated. The sophistication of which makes the human mind want to run for the cover of religious certainty. But that’s no good. This is the stuff that makes us who we are. We can’t understand ourselves by turning our back on biology and remaining stranded within our mind-scape.

In 2002, Dr. Nick Lane published “Oxygen: The Molecule That Made the World,” followed by four more books over the next two decades. The series provides perhaps the best introduction to this evolutionary, energy-exchanging, reality that science has been revealing for all serious thinkers to feast upon.

Dr. Arthur Reber brings this reality alive with his Cellular Basis of Consciousness (CBC). His book “The First Minds: Caterpillars, Karyotes, and Consciousness” is a must-read.

Likewise, in 2023 Philip Ball, former editor at the scientific journal Nature, published “How Life Works: A User’s Guide to the New Biology.” Ball takes readers on a deep dive into how gene-centric reductionism has been superseded by a growing appreciation for context and environment. Besides genes, there are complex interwoven interactive networks of subsystems, proteins, cells, tissues, along with body-wide systems, each with a degree of autonomy, yet following a game plan focused on creating a functional living animal — a self.

The “magic” happened when we had a bazillion reiterations of entities; sophistication building upon complexity; hitting upon the limits of growth; then having to find a workaround if increasing growth was to be achieved. And finding it!

What scientists are observing, down to the earliest tiniest levels of living organisms, is that life has been communicating and cooperating since the beginning. There is an evolutionary biological pageant running through from unaware entities, to awareness, to self-awareness, to introspective-self-awareness. That is, from a something to a someone.

It also helps to appreciate this was a deep-time multigenerational, ever so slow progression, with awareness being on a spectrum, and the consciousness threshold itself probably having been reached by various independent origins in different animal groups, each according to type, lifestyle, environment.

This brings me around to philosophy and David Chalmers’s p-zombie, an imaginary creature physically identical to us but with no inner life — no feeling. The claim is that, because of its “logical conceivability” thinkers are obliged to take it seriously.

It reminds me of my sixth and seventh grade at Tabor Lutheran Elementary where I was introduced to certainty and dogma. Certainly nothing like my museums and libraries and books full of curiosity, and facts, and ideas that were alive, and relevant, and accessible to me. But I digress.

Marcus Abundis has written a formidable critique with scholarly precision. Focusing on the writing of David Chalmers, specifically his 1996 “The Conscious Mind: In Search of a Fundamental Theory.” Abundis’s paper “Intelligence and the Hard Problem of Consciousness—With ‘Dual-Aspect Theory’ Notes.” Anyone who feels uncomfortable with the Hard Problem wants to read this paper:

Abundis writes in his introduction: “To begin, Chalmers sees consciousness as “a scientific problem that requires philosophical methods of understanding before we can get off the ground”, but arrives at “conclusions that some people may think of as ‘antiscientific’: I argue that reductive explanation of consciousness is impossible.”

The problem is, the more we learn about the reality of modern biology, the less conceivable the p-zombie becomes. It’s a clever puzzle, a brain teaser, a Gordian knot.

But I fear it has distracted us too much from our own physical reality, in a time when Humanity really, desperately, needed to start taking our responsibility for Earth’s physical/biological reality seriously, for a change. Requiring some deep soul searching about our human assumptions, desires expectations and where they are driving us.

Instead we got imaginary zombies.

Evolution is what created us, so leaving that out of the discussion seems to me a costly mistake.

Treating human experience as something apart from our biology and Earth’s evolution also leaves our minds estranged from this natural miracle planet we depend on for everything. But enough of what compels me to complete this project.

Dennett and Levin’s 2020 essay “Cognition all the way down,” provides an excellent response to philosophy’s heralded Hard Problem. Dr. Michael Graziano, professor of psychology and neuroscience at Princeton, is more to the point and classifies the Hard Problem as a misconception.

Graziano finds more meaning in efforts to understand the source of mind. His Attention Schema Theory (AST) is scientifically grounded, and logically has more traction than anything else that’s been offered. What it boils down to is that: Subjective awareness and consciousness are the brain’s (by necessity) simplified, internal schematic models of its own attention process. AST explains why we think and claim a Hard Problem exists.

Our human brain evolved to make complex fast close-enough accuracy possible. As Professor Picard points out, our brain did not evolve to think, it evolved to function, to successfully operate a complex creature in an unforgiving dynamic reality.

Only later with increasing creature sophistication did the need for a conception like mind arrive.

Try imagining all the internal signaling the body produces every moment, all channeled to our brain, how could it decide anything, without having a solid conception of itself? Cue up Dr. Graziano.

Now we are getting close to understanding how Earth’s creatures completed the path from something to someone. Graziano makes the point that our brain has evolved to find mind.

Not simply our own ego reflecting back upon itself, we have also evolved to look for mind in everything. Check out his “Consciousness and the Social Brain” (2013) and “Rethinking Consciousness: A Scientific Theory of Subjective Experience” (2019) for the rest of that story.

Closing paragraph pending . . .

I’m honored that you include me in this journey of yours.

It is worth it. Time has taken on new meaning after my cancer diagnosis. I don’t know any more about “how much time I have” than I did before, but there is an increased sense of urgency for accomplishing all I ever wanted to do. I am borrowing time from all the things I used to do, like hiking and my volunteer work. I know I will get back to those things, but for now my doctors say to take it easy. They also say I need to stretch, do light exercise, keep my mind engaged, and all those dang appointments. So, sometimes I feel “busy.” That and the sudden desire to sleep in the middle of the day, makes for a complicated schedule.

“feedback and Claude”
The internet never realized the dream of WIRED magazine from the 80s. Comment sections and forums can range from amazing insight to cesspools. I’m starting to see some value in AI, if used properly, but that’s what they said about nuclear energy, so, anyway.

This warms my heart. Thank you.

I will be on the lookout for more use of this word. The Minnesota Men’s Conference was just in town last week, which is mytho-poetic, but evolution gets a nod now and then.

I have given this a read-through and will spend more time with it. We are experiencing global warming here, as is everyone, but at 46 degrees N, mostly you hear about what a wonderful fall day it is. I do need the extra time to get some things taken care of so I’m heading to do that now.

Talk to you soon

Thank you,

It was good to hear from you. It brings a big smile to me knowing your medical adventure turned out positive. Congratulations.

I look forward to some good future discussions.

All the best to you Lausten.

For what it’s worth a slightly more polished version is up a Medium.com where it can be listened to, plus some pictures to break up the sections.

Why the Hard Problem of Appreciating Physical Reality?

A quick look, the pics are nice. It’s been a week. I voted, cleaned up the community garden, got my 4-wheeler off the land and back in the garage, and did a few other things, and every time I sit down to relax, my eyelids get heavy. So, patience. I don’t want to rush this.

1 Like

I used the version on Medium. I have a few other notes is you want me to expand on this.

At the end you say,

“To be clear, none of the scientists I’ve highlighted claim to have figured it all out and there are differences and disagreements — and a guarantee of future surprising revelations. “Certainty” isn’t what I’m trying to peddle here, this is about simply appreciating the state of the science and trusting in the wisdom of Earth and nature —above our ego-driven human cleverness. It’s also about appreciating that the answers to how we got from a something to a someone are to be found in evolutionary biology.”

If that really is the bottom line, then I can’t argue with it. I have made comments on tone, approach, and focus. I would say this latest effort scores well in those areas. I still get lost along the way. Often it does appear you are saying something has been figured out, but it usually would require I examine someone’s life work to make a reasoned argument.

I don’t know how we could be anything but the result of evolutionary biology. Once you cut the supernatural, where else is there to go? Panpsychism is the only science-sounding bridge to consciousness preceding biology that I know of, but you specifically rule that out.

I agree with this,

“I fear p-zombies have distracted us too much from our own physical reality. In a time when Humanity really, desperately, needed to start taking our responsibility for Earth’s physical/biological health seriously, for a change. Even though that required some deep, even painful, soul searching about our personal and societal assumptions, desires, expectations, the future and where we were driving ourselves and this Earth to.”

..except I don’t think very much of humanity would be able to describe p-zombies off the top of their head. It’s correct that philosophy has not offered up much for dealing with the changes of the last few centuries. Joseph Campbell at least floated the idea that we needed a new mythology, but that movement only got so far. You and I might find meaning and wonder in the story of the origin of the universe but instilling that in others is not easy.

Not sure where that leaves you and me.

Let me know if I missed something.

Ah but for some it served as a sort of lesson for a life time.

I remember being very impressed with the outlines of his Hero’s Journey, although I was already firmly on my path, thanks to Herman Hesse and Carl Jung - Campbell gave it an explicit form (early '90s), which was helpful.

Though I can’t remember much of his details, too busy living my own adventure to have the time for that sort of deep repeated dive. What I remember is that every time I was exposed to it, it rang true with my viscera and my spirit - so I imagine it simply soaked into my being, which was then reinforced by my life’s experiences. I remember, as seemingly lost teenager, watching Little Big Man with envy and being wow’ed by the varied lives that dude lived - now I can’t tell how great it feels to be able to look back on my own life, and its various headwinds, and think damned I collected even more fascinating chapters in my own life. Reminds me of something I saw on a water tank on Navajo Land.

Sadly, tru dat. The training has to start at toddler stage and be reinforced along the way.

Plus some great luck, being introduced to a God what was “a speck of dust that simply wanted to be more” - and finding the lesson that “it was up to me to make of life what I will.” Talk about gift from the universe. Especially since the mother with that spirit , was there to raise me to adulthood, the road, my life and women and children and bros who came my way - each relationship unique and precious.

Look at today’s total mess that our self-absorbed mindset has produced. From within the midst of the most amazing wonders that humanity had been striving to achieve for centuries. Now, we can’t see past habit and destroying the very foundation of life and civil society.

Stumbling along without a clue. Same as it ever was with all animals, but we Human’s had a short window of opportunity to transcend all that, but we couldn’t do it. We blew it.
. . Too in love with our ego and intellect, and our natural self serving nature - we dared look at ourselves through an honest scientific lens for a tiny moment in time roughly 50s-70s. But, we couldn’t stomach the thought of not being nature’s magical gift from the gods. More than that - we were convinced of being above and beyond all else that existed upon this planet. Masters with a mandate to subdue and consume.

Too much was never enough and life’s goal was all about accumulating all the toys one could before death,

That’s beside the point since the media’s metaphysical brainwashing has been predigested that p-zombie story and attitude for those who aren’t curious, or critically thinking enough to do the work themselves. Content to go along with the crowd.

I don’t have illusions of working on popular writing here. This is about explaining myself as best I can.

With you? Pretty much where we’ve always been. Now I have cause to reflect and be glad that you are still with us, part of your world and your people, doing what it is you do, appreciative of each day as it is happening, letting tomorrow take care of itself. And conversing with virtual pals now and then.

With me? Well I’ve finally cracked the Hard Problem shell and will continue to deconstruct as clearly as I can. Since first and foremost this is all about my own self-edification, and then sharing since I can’t help but believe that there are other students who also believe P’s HP is a blind ally because it hasn’t escaped its fundamental intellectual demand for magical thinking when it come to the source of our spark of awareness.

It also highlight a certain philosophical unseriousness about the reality of our Human Mind ~ Physical Reality divide. Which clearly highlights the “perceiver v. perceived” divide, with too much philosophical talk (especially the mass market street level stuff) blithely dancing on both side of the divide.

Student who believe serious science should be ready to confront and pushback on efforts to impose “psychophysical” machinations into the deliberations of serious physical biological science.

And I keep trying to refine my soundbites:

Religion is all about the glory of God and the domestication of humanity.

Philosophy is all about the glory of the Human Intellect.

Science is all about doing the best we can with what we have.